Is Creatine Worth the Hype?

If you’ve ever walked into a gym or heard about supplements, you’ve likely come across Creatine. It’s everywhere. But is it really worth all the buzz? Let’s break it down simply—especially since we’ll cover not just muscles, but your brain too.

What is Creatine?

Creatine is a natural compound. Your body makes some of it, and you get more from foods like red meat and fish. It helps your muscles produce energy, especially during short, intense efforts (like sprinting, jumping, heavy lifting). But here’s the twist: Your brain uses creatine too.

Why People Use It (Muscle & Brain)

Here are some of the main benefits that science has found so far:

Muscle/Performance Benefits

• It helps boost high-intensity exercise performance.

• It helps increase strength and lean muscle mass (when combined with training).

• It can help older adults or people in recovery preserve muscle.

Brain/Cognitive Benefits

Beyond muscles, creatine may help your brain. Here are some cognitive benefits research has uncovered:

• It can increase brain creatine levels (so the compound doesn’t just stay in muscles).  

• It may improve memory, especially short-term memory. A meta-analysis found significant improvements in memory tasks.  

• It may improve attention and processing speed (how fast you can think or respond) in some studies.  

• It seems especially helpful under stress: For example, during sleep deprivation or when the brain is “under pressure.”  

• It could be useful in older adults, diets low in creatine (vegetarians/vegans), or conditions where brain energy supply is compromised.  

So yes — creatine is one of the most-researched supplements around, and that includes brain health, not just muscle health.

So… Is It Really Worth the Hype?

Short answer: YES — but with some important “ifs.”

✅ The good:

• Because it is so well-studied, we have confidence in its muscle benefits.

• For cognitive stuff: We now have multiple studies showing some real effects (memory, attention, processing) in certain groups.

• It’s relatively safe for healthy people (in typical doses) when used properly.

⚠️ The caveats / things to know:

• Creatine is not a magic pill. You still need good training, good diet, sleep, and healthy habits for the full effect.

• Brain benefits are less consistent than muscle benefits. Some studies show small or no effects in certain tasks.  

• Benefits may depend on the person (age, diet, brain energy status). For example, people who already have “optimal” brain/creatine levels might see less of a boost.

• Doses, duration, and the exact brain tasks matter — there’s no “one size fits all” yet for brain use.

Our Verdict

YES — creatine is worth the hype for many people, especially if you are doing strength training or high-intensity exercise. And if you’re also interested in cognitive health (like memory, attention, brain energy), it’s even more interesting.

But: Don’t expect overnight miracles. Think of it as “helping your brain and body have a little extra energy reserve” rather than “crazy brain-boost in a jar.”

Quick Summary

• Creatine helps your body and brain produce energy.

• It’s one of the most researched supplements out there.

• It has strong benefits for muscle & exercise.

• It has promising benefits for brain: memory, attention, processing speed — especially under stress or in special populations.

• It works best when you pair it with good habits (training, diet, sleep).

• The brain benefits are real but modest and depend a lot on who you are and what your baseline is.

References (for curious readers)

• Systematic review/meta-analysis on cognition: “The effects of creatine supplementation on cognitive function in adults” (16 RCTs, 492 participants).  

• Review: “Creatine Supplementation and Brain Health” — looks at brain function, trauma, aging.  

• Study: “The effects of creatine supplementation on cognitive performance” (6 weeks of 5 g/day) — found a small beneficial effect.  

• Article: “Creatine supplementation: New insights and perspectives on bone and brain health” (Gatorade Sports Science Institute) — includes cognitive benefits.  

If you or someone you know is interested in physical therapy, come see one of our experienced clinicians at Restorative Therapy Co. and get relief from your symptoms! For more information about our services or to schedule an appointment, please contact us at 757-578-2958, visit www.restorativetherapyco.com or email us at info@restorativetherapyco.com. We are participating providers with a variety of insurance plans and no physician referral is needed for your initial physical therapy evaluation! We want to help you feel well and be well.

Contributed by Britni Maher, PT, DPT, MTC, CMTPT

---

Britni earned her Doctorate of Physical Therapy degree from the University of St. Augustine in 2012.

 Her areas of focus include manual therapy, dry needling, orthopedics, pre and post-surgical and spinal rehab.  Britni is a Virginia Beach local. When she’s not working with her patients, she enjoys spending time with friends and family, traveling, and chasing her dogs at the beach.